Photons: The History and Mental Models of Light Quanta

Cham: Springer Verlag (2018)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

This book focuses on the gradual formation of the concept of ‘light quanta’ or ‘photons’, as they have usually been called in English since 1926. The great number of synonyms that have been used by physicists to denote this concept indicates that there are many different mental models of what ‘light quanta’ are: simply finite, ‘quantized packages of energy’ or ‘bullets of light’? ‘Atoms of light’ or ‘molecules of light’? ‘Light corpuscles’ or ‘quantized waves’? Singularities of the field or spatially extended structures able to interfere? ‘Photons’ in G.N. Lewis’s sense, or as defined by QED, i.e. virtual exchange particles transmitting the electromagnetic force? The term ‘light quantum’ made its first appearance in Albert Einstein’s 1905 paper on a “heuristic point of view” to cope with the photoelectric effect and other forms of interaction of light and matter, but the mental model associated with it has a rich history both before and after 1905. Some of its semantic layers go as far back as Newton and Kepler, some are only fully expressed several decades later, while others initially increased in importance then diminished and finally vanished. In conjunction with these various terms, several mental models of light quanta were developed—six of them are explored more closely in this book. It discusses two historiographic approaches to the problem of concept formation: the author’s own model of conceptual development as a series of semantic accretions and Mark Turner’s model of ‘conceptual blending’. Both of these models are shown to be useful and should be explored further. This is the first historiographically sophisticated history of the fully fledged concept and all of its twelve semantic layers. It systematically combines the history of science with the history of terms and a philosophically inspired history of ideas in conjunction with insights from cognitive science.

Links

PhilArchive



    Upload a copy of this work     Papers currently archived: 91,219

External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Chapters

What is Today’s Mental Model of the Photon?

What is today’s mental model of the photon? Naively materialistic projectile or corpuscular interpretations of light were defended not only by Isaac Newton and his many nineteenth-century acolytes but by important experimental physicists from the following century, such as Johannes Stark or Arthur H... see more

Quantum Experiments with Photons Since 1945

Photon experiments in quantum mechanics are discussed. Sect. 8.1 begins with photon clumping since Hanbury Brown and Twiss 1955–57. Sects. 8.2–8.3 report about beam-splitter experiments on single photons, and single-photon interference by Taylor 1909 up to Grangier et al. . Sects. 8.4–8.5 cover Alai... see more

The ‘Light Quantum’ as a ‘Conceptual Blend’

The notion of the ‘light quantum’ is interpreted as a conceptual fusion in the sense of Gilles Fauconnier’s and Mark Turner’s ‘conceptual blending’ . The notion of a black hole can be interpreted as a superpositioning of the everyday notion of a hole in the ground onto the mathematical concept of a ... see more

Light Quanta Reflected in Textbooks and Science Teaching

How are these developments reflected in textbooks and scientific instruction? Charts and examples show how eight significant episodes in the history of the introduction of the light quantum are barely adequately or insufficiently treated in over 100 analyzed science textbooks and almost 40 practical... see more

Early Reception of the Light Quantum

If Einstein himself could not fully cope with his concept of light quanta, it is no wonder that his contemporaries would not enthusiastically rally behind it from the start either. The early reception of the concept of light quanta starts with initial skepticism by almost the entire scientific commu... see more

Early Mental Models

The mental models by early actors are presented. Sect 4.1 discusses Isaac Newton’s “globuli of light” along with amendments by some of his important adherents; the next two sections cover Einstein’s mental model of light quanta around 1909 as singularities in the radiation field, along with his doub... see more

Twelve Semantic Layers of ‘Light Quantum’ and ‘Photon’

Proceeding from the introductory propositions about semantic accretion and folds or ‘convolutions’ of meaning, we now treat the conceptual history of light quanta or photons. The twelve semantic layers forming the notion are presented: the particle model of light, starting with Newton into the ninet... see more

Planck’s and Einstein’s Pathways to Quantization

Planck’s and Einstein’s steps toward quantization are discussed, including a historical comparison of these two very different thinkers, their motives and heuristics. Sect. 2.2 studies Albert Einstein’s arguments up to the 1905 paper and how the many important publications from this annus mirabilis ... see more

Introduction

Why could it be useful to think about the complex history of a concept like the photon? The dense stratification of a dozen layers of meaning, which are fused together in this concept is still a live issue. For a deeper understanding it is instructive to study the history behind the concept and the ... see more

Summary

The six main mental models of light quanta are recapitulated: the corpuscular model, the singularity model, the binary model of photons, the wave packet, the semiclassical model and, finally, QED. My picture of the emergence and development of concepts as layered semantic accretion seems to me the m... see more

Similar books and articles

On the possible linear term in light coincidence experiments.Péter Varga - 1989 - Foundations of Physics 19 (12):1515-1523.
Atoms, entropy, quanta: Einstein's miraculous argument of 1905.John D. Norton - 2006 - Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B: Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics 37 (1):71-100.
Reasoning with conditionals.Guy Politzer - 2007 - Topoi 26 (1):79-95.

Analytics

Added to PP
2020-02-01

Downloads
15 (#893,994)

6 months
5 (#544,079)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Prof. Dr. Klaus Hentschel
Universität Stuttgart

Citations of this work

Critique of Wave-Particle Duality of Single-Photons.Varun S. Bhatta - 2021 - Journal for General Philosophy of Science / Zeitschrift für Allgemeine Wissenschaftstheorie 52 (4):501-521.
A terminological history of early elementary particle physics.Helge Kragh - 2023 - Archive for History of Exact Sciences 77 (1):73-120.
Colour, Wavelength and Turbidity in the Light of Goethe’s Colour Studies.Gopi Krishna Vijaya - 2020 - Journal for General Philosophy of Science / Zeitschrift für Allgemeine Wissenschaftstheorie 51 (4):569-594.

Add more citations

References found in this work

No references found.

Add more references