Journal of Scottish Philosophy 18 (2):193-211 (2020)
AbstractThis paper critically examines David Berman's theological lying interpretation of Hume and identifies two types of theological lying: the denial of atheism strategy and the pious Christian strategy. It is argued that neither reading successfully establishes an atheist interpretation of Hume. Moreover, circumstantial evidence shows that Hume's position was different from that of the atheists of his time. Attributions theological lying to Hume, therefore, are unwarranted and should be rejected, even if we grant that this literary technique was used in the early-modern era. Analysing other non-theistic readings of Hume is beyond the scope of this paper. However, given that Berman presents one of most elaborated atheist reinterpretations of Hume's affirmative theistic passages, the failure of Berman's analysis shows that rejecting these passages should not be the default interpretive approach, and it is reasonable to attribute to Hume a weak, indeterminate theism.
Similar books and articles
A more dangerous enemy? Philo’s “confession” and Hume’s soft atheism.Benjamin S. Cordry - 2011 - International Journal for Philosophy of Religion 70 (1):61-83.
Mysticism, evil, and Cleanthes’ dilemma.C. M. Lorkowski - 2015 - International Journal of Philosophy and Theology 76 (1):36-48.
Anglicanism, Scottish Presbyterianism, and the Irreligious Aim of Hume’s Treatise.Anders Kraal - 2013 - Hume Studies 39 (2):169-196.
Religion and Moral Prohibition in Hume’s “Of Suicide”.Thomas Holden - 2005 - Hume Studies 31 (2):189-210.
Hume’s Concealed Attack on Religion and His Early Critics.James Fieser - 1995 - Journal of Philosophical Research 20:431-449.
Hume and Collins. Two Ways of Lying Theologically.D. Berman - 1995 - In Kreimendahl (ed.), Aufklärung und Skepsis. Geburtstag, Stuttgart.
On Some Criticisms of Hume’s Principle of Proportioning Cause to Effect.John Beaudoin - 1999 - Philo 2 (2):26-40.
Hume's 'New Scene of Thought' and the Several Faces of David Hume in the Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion.Jeff Broome & John O. Nelson - 2009 - Upa.
Toward a Humean True Religion: Genuine Theism, Moderate Hope, and Practical Morality by Andre C. Willis. [REVIEW]Paul Russell - 2017 - Journal of the History of Philosophy 55 (1):168-169.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
No citations found.
References found in this work
A Treatise of Human Nature.David Hume & A. D. Lindsay - 1958 - Philosophical Quarterly 8 (33):379-380.
A Letter From a Gentleman to His Friend in Edinburgh (1745).David Hume - 1745 - Edinburgh, Edinburgh University Press.
Hume's Enlightenment Tract: The Unity and Purpose of an Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding.Stephen Buckle - 2001 - Oxford University Press UK.
Hume's Sceptical Doubts concerning Induction.Peter Millican - 2002 - In Reading Hume on Human Understanding: Essays on the First Enquiry. Clarendon Press.