Discussion de-focusing on the Wason selection task: Mental models or mental inference rules? A commentary on green and larking (1995)
Thinking and Reasoning 4 (1):83 – 94 (1998)
AbstractMental models theorists have proposed that reasoners tend to focus on what is explicit in their mental models, and that certain debiasing procedures can induce them to direct their attention to other relevant information. For instance, Green and Larking 1995; also Green, 1995a facilitated performance on the Wason selection task by inducing participants to consider counterexamples to the conditional rule. However, these authors acknowledged that one aspect of their data might require some modification to the mental models theory. This research is discussed here, and it is suggested that the results may be better accommodated by mental inference rules theory than by mental models theory.
Similar books and articles
Mental models in conditional reasoning and working memory.Pierre Barrouillet & Jean-Francois Lecas - 1999 - Thinking and Reasoning 5 (4):289 – 302.
Does reasoning occur on the selection task? A comparison of relevance-based theories.David Hardman - 1998 - Thinking and Reasoning 4 (4):353 – 376.
Induction: Representation, strategy and argument.David W. Green - 1994 - International Studies in the Philosophy of Science 8 (1):45 – 50.
Spatial inference: No difference between mental images and mental models.Markus Knauff & Christoph Schlieder - 2004 - Behavioral and Brain Sciences 27 (4):589-590.
Use or misuse of the selection task? Rejoinder to Fiddick, Cosmides, and Tooby.Dan Sperber - 2002 - Cognition 85 (3):277-290.
Evidence for mental-model-based reasoning: A comparison of reasoning with time and space concepts.Andre Vandierendonck - 1996 - Thinking and Reasoning 2 (4):249 – 272.
Discussion task demands and revising probabilities in the selection task: A comment on green, over, and Pyne.Mike Oaksford - 1998 - Thinking and Reasoning 4 (2):179 – 186.
On the information-processing demands of spatial reasoning.Sergio Morra - 2001 - Thinking and Reasoning 7 (4):347 – 365.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
No citations found.
References found in this work
Reasoning.Peter C. Wason - 1966 - In B. Foss (ed.), New Horizons in Psychology. Harmondsworth: Penguin Books. pp. 135-151.
Rationality in reasoning: The problem of deductive competence.Jonathan Evans & David E. Over - unknown - Current Psychology of Cognition 16 (1-2):3-38.
A rational analysis of the selection task as optimal data selection.Mike Oaksford & Nick Chater - 1994 - Psychological Review 101 (4):608-631.