II. The Philaids and the Chersonese

Classical Quarterly 6 (3-4):113- (1956)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

The discovery of the inscription with the name of [M]iltiades, which confirmed the statement in Dionysius Halicarnassensis 7. 3. 1 that a Miltiades was archon at Athens in 524/3, prompts a reconsideration of the problems presented by the accounts in Herodotus and in Marcellinus Life of Thucydides concerning the Philaid family. To the question, who is this Miltiades, the following answers have been given. ‘He is not a Philaid.’ The objection to this answer is that the Peisistratids either occupied the archonship themselves or gave it to members of leading families, such as Cleisthenes the Alcmeonid in 525/4; if then this Miltiades was a member of a leading family, he is almost certainly a member of the Philaid family. ‘He is the elder Miltiades who founded the settlement in the Chersonese.’ In Herodotus' account Miltiades left Athens, where he was already powerful, at the beginning of a tyranny by Peisistratus; then after several operations in the Chersonese Miltiades was rescued by Croesus. The year in which Miltiades left Athens was either 561/0 or 556/5 and almost certainly the latter; for in 561/0 Croesus was not on the throne. The year 546 may be excluded; for in 546 autumn and winter Croesus had neither the time nor the opportunity to concern himself with Miltiades, since Cyrus was then at war with Lydia and seized Sardis.2 If Miltiades was powerful in 556/5, he was at that date no youngster but at least in his thirties—a man born say c. 590. In 524/3, being well on in his sixties and having spent thirty years and more in the Chersonese, this Miltiades is unlikely to have been the eponymous archon. We conclude, then, that the archon Miltiades in 524/3 was a different and younger Miltiades. Having cleared the ground on these two points, I turn to the central problem, whether there were two men called Miltiades, one born c. 590 and the other the general who died of a wound soon after 489, or whether there were three men called Miltiades, one of whom was in a generation intermediate between Miltiades born c. 590 and Miltiades dead c. 489. Either solution is chronologically possible.

Links

PhilArchive



    Upload a copy of this work     Papers currently archived: 92,038

External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Similar books and articles

Marathon.N. G. L. Hammond - 1961 - The Classical Review 11 (03):262-.
Thermopylae.N. G. L. Hammond - 1963 - The Classical Review 13 (03):316-.
James Edwin Creighton.Wm A. Hammond - 1925 - Journal of Philosophy 22 (10):253-256.
On `sensation'.Albert L. Hammond - 1944 - Philosophical Review 53 (3):260-285.
Relativity and representativeness.Kenneth R. Hammond - 1951 - Philosophy of Science 18 (3):208-211.
The dependence of thought.Albert L. Hammond - 1926 - Philosophical Review 35 (5):416-433.
The effectiveness of thought.Albert L. Hammond - 1927 - Philosophical Review 36 (6):517-534.

Analytics

Added to PP
2010-12-09

Downloads
24 (#658,023)

6 months
6 (#522,810)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Citations of this work

Herodotus and Histiæus.A. Blamire - 1959 - Classical Quarterly 9 (3-4):142-.
Lemnos, Cimon, and the Hephaisteion.Jeremy McInerney - 2021 - Classical Antiquity 40 (1):151-193.
Herodotus and Histiæus1.A. Blamire - 1959 - Classical Quarterly 9 (3-4):142-154.

Add more citations

References found in this work

No references found.

Add more references