A Critique of Susanne Langer’s View of Musical Temporality

Proceedings of the European Society for Aesthetics, Vol. 10 (2018)
  Copy   BIBTEX


Susanne Langer’s idea of the primary apparition of music involves a dichotomy between two kinds of temporality: “felt time” and “clock time.” For Langer, musical time is exclusively felt time, and in this sense, music is “time made audible.” However, Langer also postulates what we would call ‘a strong suspension thesis’: the swallowing up of clock time in the illusion of felt time. In this paper we take issue with the ‘strong suspension thesis’ and its implications and ramifications regarding not only musical meaning, but also the purported metaphysics of music construed as essentially inhering in felt time. We argue that this thesis is overstated and misdirecting insofar as it purports to describe what we experience when we hear music with understanding. We discuss a selection of examples of repetitive formations, from mediaeval music to contemporary music, which show that persistent, motion-inhibiting repetition undermines the listener’s ability to identify order and coherence due to a relative inability to anticipate the next occurrence of a differentiating musical event. We argue that Langer’s one-sided view of musical temporality, which patently relies on the conceptual framework of memory time and the specious present, exemplifies what we propose to call ‘the searchlight model of musical understanding,’ wherein the constant span of illumination of the searchlight (representing the span of the specious present) moves continuously parallel to, and along, its postulated target, i.e., the music heard, as it ‘illuminates’ it. We argue that, in the last analysis, memory time conceptually presupposes the publicly identifiable means of chronometric length. One maintains the ‘strong suspension thesis’ on pain of conceptual confusion.



External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Similar books and articles

El tiempo en las filosofías románticas de la música.Lewis Rowell - 1996 - Anuario Filosófico 29 (54):125-168.
Music and pain.Andreas Dorschel - 2011 - In Jane Fulcher (ed.), The Oxford Handbook of the New Cultural History of Music. Oxford University Press. pp. 68-79.
Musik und Schmerz.Andreas Dorschel - 2008 - Musiktheorie 23 (3):257-263.
Znaczenie Muzyki - Znaczenia w Muzyce : Próba Ogólnej Teorii na Tle Estetyki Susanne Langer.Krzysztof Guczalski - 1999 - Kraków, Polska: Musica Iagellonica. Edited by Susanne Katherina Knauth Langer.
Musical time: the sense of order.Barbara R. Barry - 1990 - Stuyvesant, NY: Pendragon Press.


Added to PP

216 (#83,095)

6 months
52 (#71,898)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Eran Guter
Max Stern Yezreel Valley College

Citations of this work

No citations found.

Add more citations