Problems with the defetishization thesis: ethical consumerism, alternative food systems, and commodity fetishism [Book Review]
Agriculture and Human Values 31 (1):109-117 (2014)
AbstractThe defetishization thesis claims alternative markets can lead to a more honest, less mystified relationship with food production and, in turn, strengthen civil society. Drawing from Marxian political economic and environmental sociological theory, I make three general claims: capitalism is inherently ecologically and socially harmful; “ethical” commodities derived from alternative markets cannot fundamentally counteract the pervasiveness and scale of ; and, because of and, ethical consumerism does not defetishize the commodity form, but acts as a new layer of commodity fetishism that masks the harms of capitalism by convincing society that the harms of capitalism can be rehabilitated with the commodity form itself. Prescriptively, I argue traditional, large-scale political tactics would be needed for “defetishization” to take place
Similar books and articles
A Cultural Economy Model for Studying Food Systems.Jane Dixon - 1999 - Agriculture and Human Values 16 (2):151-160.
Fields of Cultural Contradictions: Lessons From the Tobacco Patch. [REVIEW]D. Wynne Wright - 2005 - Agriculture and Human Values 22 (4):465-477.
Not in My Body: BGH and the Rise of Organic Milk. [REVIEW]E. Melanie DuPuis - 2000 - Agriculture and Human Values 17 (3):285-295.
The Capitalist Composition of Organic: The Potential of Markets in Fulfilling the Promise of Organic Agriculture. [REVIEW]Patricia Allen & Martin Kovach - 2000 - Agriculture and Human Values 17 (3):221-232.
Choosing a Food Future: Differentiating Among Alternative Food Options. [REVIEW]Jeffrey R. Follett - 2009 - Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 22 (1):31-51.
Reweaving the Food Security Safety Net: Mediating Entitlement and Entrepreneurship. [REVIEW]Patricia Allen - 1999 - Agriculture and Human Values 16 (2):117-129.
Fair-Trade Coffee and Commodity Fetishism: The Limits of Market-Driven Social Justice.Gavin Fridell - 2007 - Historical Materialism 15 (4):79-104.
The End of the Green Revolution.Scott D. Soby - 2013 - Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 26 (3):537-546.
I. Marx's Analysis of Commodity Exchange—a Reply to Carver.Ulrich Steinvorth - 1976 - Inquiry: An Interdisciplinary Journal of Philosophy 19 (1-4):99 – 108.
Food Citizenship: Is There a Duty for Responsible Consumption? [REVIEW]Johan Tavernier - 2012 - Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 25 (6):895-907.
Food Citizenship: Is There a Duty for Responsible Consumption? [REVIEW]Johan De Tavernier - 2012 - Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics 25 (6):895-907.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
On (Not) Knowing Where Your Food Comes From: Meat, Mothering and Ethical Eating.Kate Cairns & Josée Johnston - 2018 - Agriculture and Human Values 35 (3):569-580.
The Nature of Urban Gardens: Toward a Political Ecology of Urban Agriculture.Michael Classens - 2015 - Agriculture and Human Values 32 (2):229-239.
Governance for global stewardship: can private certification move beyond commodification in fostering sustainability transformations?Agni Kalfagianni, Lena Partzsch & Miriam Beulting - 2020 - Agriculture and Human Values 37 (1):65-81.
Malign and Benign Neglect: A Local Food System and the Myth of Sustainable Redevelopment in Appalachia Ohio.Angela M. Chapman & Harold A. Perkins - 2020 - Agriculture and Human Values 37 (1):113-127.
Extending Ethical Consumerism Theory to Semi-Legal Sectors: Insights From Recreational Cannabis.Elizabeth A. Bennett - 2018 - Agriculture and Human Values 35 (2):295-317.
References found in this work
One-Dimensional Man: Studies in the Ideology of Advanced Industrial Society.Herbert Marcuse - 1964 - Routledge.
History and Class Consciousness: Studies in Marxist Dialectics.Georg Lukacs - 1971 - MIT Press.