Okay, Google, Can I Trust You? An Anti-trust Argument for Antitrust

In Mark Alfano & David Collins (eds.), The Moral Psychology of Trust. Lexington Books. pp. 237-257 (2023)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

In this chapter, I argue that it is impossible to trust the Big Tech companies, in an ethically important sense of trust. The argument is not that these companies are untrustworthy. Rather, I argue that the power to hold the trustee accountable is a necessary component of this sense of trust, and, because these companies are so powerful, they are immune to our attempts, as individuals or nation-states, to hold them to account. It is, therefore, literally impossible to trust Big Tech. After introducing the accounts of trust and power that I deploy, I argue that Big Tech companies have four kinds of power that render them unaccountable: fiscal power, political power, data power, and cognitive power. I conclude by reflecting on recent calls to break up the Big Tech firms, suggesting a new antitrust test in the light of my arguments.

Similar books and articles

Tech Ethics Through Trust Auditing.Matthew Grellette - 2022 - Science and Engineering Ethics 28 (3):1-15.
Privacy and Surveillance.Roos Slegers - 2023 - In Wim Dubbink & Willem van der Deijl (eds.), Business Ethics: A Philosophical Introduction. Springer Nature Switzerland. pp. 177-186.
Big Tech and the Smartification of Agriculture.Anna-Verena Nosthoff & Felix Maschewski - 2022 - Https://Projects.Itforchange.Net/State-of-Big-Tech/Big-Tech-and-the-Smartification-of-Agriculture-a-Critical-Perspective/.
Trusting patients, trusting nurses.Derek Sellman - 2007 - Nursing Philosophy 8 (1):28-36.

Analytics

Added to PP
2023-03-11

Downloads
230 (#13,470)

6 months
108 (#160,087)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Trystan S. Goetze
Cornell University

Citations of this work

No citations found.

Add more citations