Opacity of Character: Virtue Ethics and the Legal Admissibility of Character Evidence

Philosophical Issues 31 (1):334-354 (2021)
  Copy   BIBTEX


Many jurisdictions prohibit or severely restrict the use of evidence about a defendant’s character to prove legal culpability. Situationists, who argue that conduct is largely determined by situational features rather than by character, can easily defend this prohibition. According to situationism, character evidence is misleading or paltry. Proscriptions on character evidence seem harder to justify, however, on virtue ethical accounts. It appears that excluding character evidence either denies the centrality of character for explaining conduct—the situationist position—or omits probative evidence. Situationism is, after all, presented as antithetical to virtue ethics. This essay provides a virtue ethical defense of character evidence exclusion rules. We show that existing virtue ethical rebuttals to situationism themselves support prohibitions on character evidence; even if behavior arises from stable character traits, character evidence should be prohibited. In building our case, we provide a taxonomy of kinds of character judgment and reconcile the ubiquity and reasonableness of character judgments in ordinary life with the epistemic legitimacy of character evidence prohibitions in law.

Similar books and articles

Virtue Ethics and Social Psychology.P. Lunt - 2007 - History and Philosophy of Psychology 7 (1):365-392.
Character and Situationism: New Directions.Christian B. Miller - 2017 - Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 20 (3):459-471.
Dewey, Situationism, And Moral Education.Matthew Pamental - 2009 - Educational Theory 59 (2):147-166.
Virtue ethics and situationist personality psychology.Maria Merritt - 2000 - Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 3 (4):365-383.
Virtue, Vice, and Situationism.Tom Bates & Pauline Kleingeld - 2018 - In Nancy E. Snow (ed.), The Oxford Handbook of Virtue. Oxford: Oxford University Press. pp. 524-545.


Added to PP

238 (#52,359)

6 months
98 (#8,609)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author Profiles

Georgi Gardiner
University of Tennessee, Knoxville
Jacob Smith
University of Virginia

Citations of this work

Defining Wokeness.J. Spencer Atkins - forthcoming - Social Epistemology:1-19.

Add more citations

References found in this work

Nicomachean ethics.H. Aristotle & Rackham - 2014 - Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing Co..
Knowledge in a Social World.Alvin Ira Goldman - 1999 - Oxford, England: Oxford University Press.
The Sovereignty of Good.Iris Murdoch - 1970 - New York: Schocken Books.

View all 31 references / Add more references