Autonomy, slavery, and mill's critique of paternalism

Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 4 (3):231-251 (2001)
  Copy   BIBTEX


Critics have charged that John Stuart Mill''s discussion as of paternalism in On Liberty is internally inconsistent, noting, for example, the numerous instances in which Mill explicitly endorses examples of paternalistic coercion. Similarly, commentators have noted an apparent contradiction between Mill''s political liberalism – according to which the state should be neutral among competing conceptions of the good – and Mill''s condemnation of non-autonomous ways of life, such as that of a servile wife. More generally, critics have argued that while Mill professes an allegiance to utilitarianism, he actually abandons it in favor of a view that values personal autonomy as the greatest intrinsic good. This paper presents an interpretation of Mill that provides a viable and consistent treatment of paternalism, thereby refuting each of the aforementioned critiques. Mill''s views, it argues, are consistently utilitarian. Moreover, the interpretation accounts for all of Mill''s departures from his otherwise blanket prohibition of paternalistic legislation. In particular, it explains his most notorious example, the condemnation of voluntary contracts for slavery. The interpretation emphasizes Mill''s conceptual linkage between autonomy and utility, noting his implicit use of at least three different senses of the notion of autonomy.



    Upload a copy of this work     Papers currently archived: 89,764

External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Similar books and articles

Getting mill right.Deni Elliott - 2007 - Journal of Mass Media Ethics 22 (2-3):100 – 112.
Utilitarianism.John Stuart Mill - 2009 - In Steven M. Cahn (ed.), Exploring Philosophy: An Introductory Anthology. Oxford University Press.
Mill on Happiness.S. Evan Kreider - 2010 - Philosophical Papers 39 (1):53-68.
On Millgram on mill.Dale E. Miller - 2004 - Utilitas 16 (1):96-108.
Mill, Paternalism, and Slavery.John D. Hodson - 1980 - Analysis 41 (1):60 - 62.
Brown on Mill’s moral theory: A critical response.Dale E. Miller - 2010 - Politics, Philosophy and Economics 9 (1):47-66.
Mills liberalism and liberalism's posterity.John Gray - 2000 - The Journal of Ethics 4 (1-2):137-165.


Added to PP

122 (#134,734)

6 months
3 (#435,525)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Citations of this work

Paternalism, part II.David J. Garren - 2007 - Philosophical Books 48 (1):50-59.
J. S. Mill on Coolie Labour and Voluntary Slavery.David Schwan - 2013 - British Journal for the History of Philosophy 21 (4):754-766.
The harm principle and the greatest happiness principle: the missing link.Cinara Nahra - 2014 - Kriterion: Journal of Philosophy 55 (129):99-110.
The Tacit Concept of Competence in J. S. Mill's On Liberty.Thomas Nys - 2006 - South African Journal of Philosophy 25 (4):305-328.

Add more citations

References found in this work

A System of Logic, Ratiocinative and Inductive.John Stuart Mill - 1843 - New York and London,: University of Toronto Press. Edited by J. Robson.

Add more references