In
Against the Philosophical Tide. Yeovil: Critias Publishing. pp. 187-189 (
2020)
Copy
BIBTEX
Abstract
In ‘Aeon’ magazine (2 August 2017), Professor Paul Russell claims that tolerance demands that criticism of ideologies be permitted; but it also demands that criticism of natural identities be suppressed. He says that the Left’s failure to distinguish ideological from non-ideological identities has led identity politics into intolerance. I argue that Russell’s position is self-contradictory, implying that his (ideological) liberal identity both should and should not be open to criticism. Tolerance must be extended to criticism of non-ideological identities. Laws against ‘hate speech’ are incompatible with tolerance.