Building a Science of Animal Minds: Lloyd Morgan, Experimentation, and Morgan’s Canon

Journal of the History of Biology 50 (3):525-569 (2017)
  Copy   BIBTEX


Conwy Lloyd Morgan (1852–1936) is widely regarded as the father of modern comparative psychology. Yet, Morgan initially had significant doubts about whether a genuine science of comparative psychology was even possible, only later becoming more optimistic about our ability to make reliable inferences about the mental capacities of non-human animals. There has been a fair amount of disagreement amongst scholars of Morgan’s work about the nature, timing, and causes of this shift in Morgan’s thinking. We argue that Morgan underwent two quite different shifts of attitude towards the proper practice of comparative psychology. The first was a qualified acceptance of the Romanesian approach to comparative psychology that he had initially criticized. The second was a shift away from Romanes’ reliance on systematizing anecdotal evidence of animal intelligence towards an experimental approach, focused on studying the development of behaviour. We emphasize the role of Morgan’s evolving epistemological views in bringing about the first shift – in particular, his philosophy of science. We emphasize the role of an intriguing but overlooked figure in the history of comparative psychology in explaining the second shift, T. Mann Jones, whose correspondence with Morgan provided an important catalyst for Morgan’s experimental turn, particularly the special focus on development. We also shed light on the intended function of Morgan’s Canon, the methodological principle for which Morgan is now mostly known. The Canon can only be properly understood by seeing it in the context of Morgan’s own unique experimental vision for comparative psychology.

Similar books and articles

Doing away with morgan’s canon.Simon Fitzpatrick - 2008 - Mind and Language 23 (2):224–246.
Morgan’s Canon Revisited.Sean Allen-Hermanson - 2005 - Philosophy of Science 72 (4):608-31.
What use is Morgan's canon?Martin Montminy - 2005 - Philosophical Psychology 18 (4):399-414.
An Introduction to Comparative Psychology.C. Lloyd Morgan - 1903 - London: Walter Scott Publishing.
Comparative and Genetic Psychology.C. Lloyd Morgan - 1905 - Philosophical Review 14:631.
Comparative and genetic psychology.Lloyd Morgan - 1905 - Psychological Review 12 (2-3):78-97.
Marx and Morgan.William H. Shaw - 1984 - History and Theory 23 (2):215-228.
Head or tail? de morgan on the bounds of traditional logic.Víctor Sánchez Valencia - 1997 - History and Philosophy of Logic 18 (3):123-138.


Added to PP

2,075 (#4,294)

6 months
285 (#7,761)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author Profiles

Simon Fitzpatrick
John Carroll University
Grant Goodrich
University of Northern Iowa

Citations of this work

Morgan’s Quaker gun and the species of belief.Devin Sanchez Curry - 2023 - Philosophical Perspectives 37 (1):119-144.
Darwin, Hume, Morgan, and the verae causae of psychology.Hayley Clatterbuck - 2016 - Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part C: Studies in History and Philosophy of Biological and Biomedical Sciences 60 (C):1-14.
Conwy Lloyd Morgan, Methodology, and the Origins of Comparative Psychology.Evan Arnet - 2019 - Journal of the History of Biology 52 (3):433-461.
On the origins of physical cognition in corvids.Ivo Jacobs - 2017 - Dissertation, Lund University

Add more citations