Abstract

The case presented here is tragic, not just in the sense of being a sad story, but in the dramatic meaning of tragedy. It presents us with a situation where there is no clear path, where moral ambiguity exists, and where no possible solution could unequivocally be declared the right or good one. Ethical deliberation can help here, but only as a way of clarifying the issues and offering reasonable solutions. It cannot show us the one right way.Baby G has profound medical conditions, including respiratory failure, a chest wall deformity that will require surgery, and profound neurodevelopmental disability. Even a best case scenario portends a shortened lifespan and..