Enseñar la sophrosyne: el uso del elenchos del Sócrates de Jenofonte [Traducción de Facundo Bey y Julia Rabanal]

Archai: Revista de Estudos Sobre as Origens Do Pensamento Ocidental 2021 (31):1-39 (2021)
  Copy   BIBTEX


In contrast to the abundance of discussion of Plato’s portrayal of the Socratic elenchos, relatively little work has been done on the elenchos as it appears in Xenophon. The reason is obvious: Xenophon makes much less use of the elenchus than Plato and what he does offer is not as interesting philosophically. Nevertheless, there are good reasons to look more closely at Xenophon’s portrait. It provides a corrective to the excessively intellectualizing portrait of the elenchus found in Plato’s writings, and exhibits an educational quality that is characteristic of ancient Greek attitudes but not always stressed in treatments of Socrates. In the introduction to Bandini and Dorion 2000-2010, cxviii-clxxxii, Louis-André Dorion offers a probing analysis of the term elenchos as used by Xenophon and a broad survey of the elenchoi in Xenophon’s Socratic writings. Although Xenophon’s Socrates sometimes uses argumentation reminiscent of his Platonic cousin, this is only a minor part of his over-all conversational repertoire. Education is accomplished not by interrogation but by the direct and open communication of doctrine and by the practice of virtue (askēsis: see Mem. i 2.23, ii 1.1). Rather than employing the elenchos, Xenophon’s Socrates generally spends his time offering abundant useful advice to his friends. According to Dorion, Xenophon’s scant use of the elenchos is a result of his deep skepticism about its educational value. As a result of this skepticism, Xenophon creates an alternative portrait of Socrates in which interrogation plays a much smaller role. Dorion is certainly right to note that the elenchos is far less important for Xenophon than for Plato, but his conclusion is somewhat extreme. Although Xenophon does not focus on the Socratic elenchos, he does offer some portraits of it and he does not contest Plato’s fuller portrait of it either. This is because the elenchos does have some value for Xenophon, even if this value differs from what we may assume is its value in the Platonic portrait. As Morrison 1994 has shown, the elenchos serves a valuable role in selecting or preparing students for more substantive lessons. It can also play a valuable role in training for and acting in political affairs. And the elenchos can serve an educational role in another way, by contributing directly to the acquisition of virtue (sophrosune) by the interlocutor. I shall trace these significant roles of the elenchos for Xenophon.

Similar books and articles

On Professor VIastos’ Xenophon.Donald Morrison - 1987 - Ancient Philosophy 7:9-22.
Remembering socrates: Philosophical essays (review).Anthony K. Jensen - 2008 - Journal of the History of Philosophy 46 (4):pp. 631-632.
Symposium. Xenophon - 1998 - Aris & Phillips.
Plato's Statesman and Xenophon's Cyrus.Carol Atack - 2018 - In Gabriel Danzig, Donald Morrison & David M. Johnson (eds.), Plato and Xenophon: comparative studies. Leiden, Netherlands: pp. 510-543.
Xenophon's Socrates on Wisdom and Action.Joseph Bjelde - 2021 - Classical Quarterly 71 (2):560-574.
Memorablia, Apology, Symposium, Oeconomicus. Xenophon - 2011 - Hackett Publishing Company.
Socrates and Gregory Vlastos: The Power of Elenchos in the "Gorgias".Asli Gocer - 1994 - Dissertation, University of Massachusetts Amherst


Added to PP

127 (#103,346)

6 months
78 (#18,140)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author Profiles

Gabriel Danzig
Bar-Ilan University, Ramat Gan
Facundo Bey
Instituto de Filosofía "Ezequiel de Olaso" (INEO) - CONICET

Citations of this work

No citations found.

Add more citations

References found in this work

The socratic elenchus.Gregory Vlastos - 1982 - Journal of Philosophy 79 (11):711-714.
The Socratic Elenchus.Gregory Vlastos - 1999 - In Gail Fine (ed.), Plato 1: Metaphysics and Epistemology. Oxford University Press.
Plato's Earlier Dialectic.Richard Robinson - 1953 - London, UK: Oxford University Press.
Plato's earlier dialectic. [REVIEW]Richard Robinson - 1954 - Revue de Métaphysique et de Morale 59 (1):81-84.
The Problem of the Elenchus Reconsidered.Hugh H. Benson - 1987 - Ancient Philosophy 7:67-85.

View all 9 references / Add more references