Norman Geras’s Political Thought From Marxism to Human Rights: Controversy and Analysis

Cham: Springer Verlag (2018)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

This book provides a critical account of the main controversies involving Norman Geras, one of the key modern political thinkers. It moves from his youthful Trotskyism on to his book on Rosa Luxemburg, then his classic account of Marx and human nature, and his highly regarded discussion of Marx and justice. Following this, Geras tried to elaborate a Marxist theory of justice, which involved taking on-board aspects of liberalism. Next he attacked the post modernism of Laclau and Mouffe and criticised Rorty’s pragmatism, and then elaborated a contract of mutual indifference from a detailed study of the Holocaust. Lastly he wrote a book on human rights and humanitarian intervention, defending the 2003 invasion of Iraq. Cowling varies from exposition and admiration, to ideas about how Geras’s work should be interpreted, to criticism of his Trotskyism and of his support for the invasion of Iraq. The book will appeal to readers interested in Norman Geras and Marxism in particular, and social and political theory in general.

Links

PhilArchive



    Upload a copy of this work     Papers currently archived: 91,349

External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Chapters

Geras and Postmodernism 2: Richard Rorty

This chapter generally commends Geras’s critique of Richard Rorty’s Contingency, Irony and Solidarity. He concurs with Geras’s claim against Rorty that there is such a thing as human nature, and that Rorty implicitly uses assumptions about human nature in various ways. Cowling admires Geras’s extens... see more

Geras and Postmodernism 1: Laclau and Mouffe

This chapter commends Geras’s critique of Laclau and Mouffe’s book Hegemony and Social Strategy. Cowling starts by pointing out that Geras is one of a number of critics of postmodernism, and gives a brief account of some of the main features of postmodernism, and some of the lines of criticism that ... see more

Marxism, Socialism and Morality

This chapter discusses various attempts that Geras made to elaborate a Marxist theory of justice. Cowling agrees with Geras that ‘to each according to his needs’ cannot possibly refer to any resources whatsoever that someone might need. Geras comments that providing everybody with a basic decent exi... see more

Marx and Justice

This chapter provides an exposition of two articles in which Geras provided a widely admired account of the extensive literature discussing whether or not Marx had a theory of justice, and the major pieces of evidence from Marx’s work that point in one direction or the other. Geras reaches the class... see more

Geras and Althusser

This chapter discusses two short articles that Geras wrote about Althusser. Geras had already established that Marx had a theory of human nature, which was held continuously from 1844 onwards, and therefore has a good basis for disputing Althusser’s claim that in the older Marx there is no theory of... see more

Marx and Human Nature

This chapter reviews one of Geras’s most important contributions to the study of Marx, his account of Marx’s view of human nature. Geras provides a relatively thin account of human nature, which he finds in Marx. It is based not on the idea of alienated man but on a series of basic human needs, of w... see more

Geras and Trotskyism

The chapter examines Geras’s earlier writings on Trotsky and Trotskyism. Geras accepted the idea of permanent revolution, regarded Trotsky as a democratic figure, admired his prescient analysis of the rise of Nazism, and admired Trotsky as a literary figure. Cowling argues that this was one of the w... see more

The Legacy of Rosa Luxemburg

This chapter discusses Geras’s first book, on Rosa Luxemburg. Geras gives a good account of the notion of capitalist collapse implied in the slogan ‘socialism or barbarism?’, but Cowling argues that Geras should have said more about Luxemburg’s economic theory, which underpins this slogan. Geras dis... see more

Introduction

In this chapter Cowling provides a very brief outline of the life of Norman Geras, starting from his boyhood in Rhodesia, with the awareness that came from being Jewish in a racist society, on to his life as a Marxist lecturer and eventually Professor at the University of Manchester. There are brief... see more

Conclusion

In this concluding chapter Cowling starts by emphasizing that he finds every reason to deeply admire Geras’s work. Cowling then raises three questions. First, Geras seems to implicitly move away from his youthful Trotskyism, but never really gets to grips with the extent to which he has departed. Se... see more

Crimes Against Humanity

In this chapter Cowling discusses Geras’s final book on Crimes against Humanity, in which Geras identifies the major features of crimes against humanity, and proceeds from these to develop the idea of a duty of humanitarian intervention, identifying a number of criteria on which it might be justifie... see more

The Contract of Mutual Indifference

This lengthy chapter discusses what is generally acknowledged to be some of Geras’s finest work, developed from his extensive knowledge of the Holocaust. He was particularly interested in the relative indifference of bystanders to the fate of Jews. Cowling challenges this, emphasizing that Germans c... see more

The Enlightenment and Modernity

This brief chapter discusses an excellent edited collection put together by Geras on the Enlightenment. There is a simplistic view of the Enlightenment based on the ideas of Foucault, which sees it as the locus of a new form of discipline, linked to particular reorientations of knowledge. It tends t... see more

Similar books and articles

Seven Types of Obloquy: Travesties of Marxism.Norman Geras - 1991 - Graduate Faculty Philosophy Journal 14 (1):77-115.
The Enlightenment and modernity.Norman Geras & Robert Wokler (eds.) - 1999 - New York: St. Martin's Press.
Values Priority and Human Rights Policy.Hong Xiao - 2005 - Journal of Human Values 11 (2):87-102.
The Sovereignty of Human Rights.Patrick Macklem - 2015 - Oxford University Press USA.
The Subject of Rights.Peg Birmingham - 2011 - Epoché: A Journal for the History of Philosophy 16 (1):139-156.
Crime Against Humanity: A Defence of the ‘Subsidiarity’ View.Richard Vernon - 2013 - Canadian Journal of Law and Jurisprudence 26 (1):229-242.

Analytics

Added to PP
2020-01-31

Downloads
3 (#1,682,188)

6 months
2 (#1,263,261)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?