South African Journal of Philosophy 36 (4):541-552 (2017)

Wehan Coombs
University of Pretoria
The possibility of a harmony between the psychological doctrine of Aristotle and that of Plato marks a significant issue within the context of the debate surrounding Aristotle’s putative opposition to or harmony with Plato’s philosophy. The standard interpretation of Aristotle’s conception of the soul being purely hylomorphic leaves no room for harmonisation with Plato, nor does a functionalist interpretation that reduces Aristotle’s psychological doctrine to physicalist terms. However, these interpretations have serious drawbacks, both in terms of ad-hoc explanations formulated in the developmentalist mode, and the misconstruing of some of the fundamental features of Aristotle’s psychological doctrine. A dualist interpretation that accepts Aristotle’s doctrine of some part of the soul being properly incorporeal, separable and immortal overcomes these drawbacks and, significantly, opens the door for Platonic harmonisation. Furthermore, it can be shown that the kind of immortality in question is also in line with the Platonic stance, due to a deep similarity between the conceptions of metaphysical and moral personhood held by Plato and his student. However, this Aristotelian dualism is not Platonic dualism simpliciter. Rather, it is best understood in terms of the division of labour between Aristotle and Plato suggested by the Neoplatonic commentators generally, and Simplicius in particular. I argue that though questions surrounding these issues and particularly the issue of reincarnation remain, an account of Aristotle’s psychological doctrine as dualist and in harmony with Plato’s view of the soul can be shown to be stronger than both standard hylomorphic and functionalist accounts, both exegetically and philosophically.
Keywords Plato  Aristotle  Neoplatonism  Soul  Immortality
Categories (categorize this paper)
DOI 10.1080/02580136.2017.1385951
Edit this record
Mark as duplicate
Export citation
Find it on Scholar
Request removal from index
Revision history

Download options

PhilArchive copy

Upload a copy of this paper     Check publisher's policy     Papers currently archived: 65,784
External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server
Configure custom proxy (use this if your affiliation does not provide a proxy)
Through your library

References found in this work BETA

Hylomorphism and Functionalism.S. Marc Cohen - 1992 - In Martha Nussbaum & Amelie Rorty (eds.), Essays on Aristotle’s De Anima. Clarendon Press. pp. 57-73.
After the Ascent: Plato on Becoming Like God.John M. Armstrong - 2004 - Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy 26:171-183.
Mind and Imagination in Aristotle.Christopher Shields - 1992 - Philosophical Review 101 (2):371.
Soul and Body in Aristotle.Christopher Shields - 1988 - Oxford Studies in Ancient Philosophy 6:103.
Aristotle and the Mind-Body Problem.Robert Heinaman - 1990 - Phronesis 35 (1):83-102.

View all 17 references / Add more references

Citations of this work BETA

No citations found.

Add more citations

Similar books and articles

Aristotle's Theory of Music Education.Yang Lu - 2006 - Nankai University (Philosophy and Social Sciences) 3:92-96.
Aristotle on Vice.Jozef Müller - 2015 - British Journal for the History of Philosophy 23 (3):459-477.
Re-Calling.Stephen David Ross - 2010 - International Studies in Philosophy Monograph Series:21-41.
The Harmony of Plato and Aristotle.Matthew S. Linck - 2006 - Philosophy in the Contemporary World 13 (2):38-44.
The Soul of the Greeks: An Inquiry.Michael Davis - 2011 - University of Chicago Press.
The Constitution of the Human Body in Plato’s Timaeus.Filip Karfík - 2012 - Croatian Journal of Philosophy 12 (2):167-181.
Plato's Affinity Argument for the Immortality of the Soul.David Apolloni - 1996 - Journal of the History of Philosophy 34 (1):5-32.
Plato's Affinity Argument for the Immortality of the Soul.David Apolloni - 1996 - Journal of the History of Philosophy 34:5-32.
Plato on the Limits of Human Life.Sara Brill - 2013 - Indiana University Press.
« Immortel » Et « Impérissable » Dans le Phédon de Platon.Denis O'Brien - 2007 - International Journal of the Platonic Tradition 1 (2):109-262.


Added to PP index

Total views
55 ( #198,519 of 2,463,161 )

Recent downloads (6 months)
2 ( #299,149 of 2,463,161 )

How can I increase my downloads?


My notes