A Biosemiotic Ontology : The Philosophy of Giorgio Prodi

Springer Verlag (2018)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

Giorgio Prodi was an important Italian scientist who developed an original philosophy based on two basic assumptions: 1. life is mainly a semiotic phenomenon; 2. matter is somewhat a semiotic phenomenon. Prodi applies Peirce's cenopythagorean categories to all phenomena of life and matter: Firstness, Secondness, and Thirdness. They are interconnected meaning that the very ontology of the world, according to Prodi, is somewhat semiotic. In fact, when one describes matter as “made of” Firstness and Secondness, this means that matter ‘intrinsically’ implies semiotics. At the very heart of Prodi’s theory lies a metaphysical hypothesis which is an ambitious theoretical gesture that places Prodi in an awkward position with respect to the customary philosophical tradition. In fact, his own ontology is neither dualistic nor monistic. Such a conclusion is unusual and weird, but much less unusual in present time than it was when it was first introduced. The actual resurgence of various “realisms” make Prodi’s semiotic realism much more interesting than when he first proposed his philosophical approach. What is uncommon, in Prodi perspective, is that he never separated semiotics from the materiality of the world. Prodi does not agree with the “standard” structuralist view of semiosis as an artificial and unnatural activity. On the contrary, Prodi believed semiosis lies at the very bottom of life. On one hand, Prodi maintains a strong realist stance; on the other, a realism that includes semiosis as ‘natural’ phenomena. This last view is very unusual because all forms, more or less, of realism exclude semiosis from nature but they frequently “reduce” semiosis to non-semiotic elements. According to Prodi, semiosis is a completely natural phenomenon.

Links

PhilArchive



    Upload a copy of this work     Papers currently archived: 91,386

External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Chapters

Breaking the Circle

Prodi explains semiosic phenomena by means of the model of the circle. This model allows to account for a very important feature of the natural world: in lifeLife phenomena, there is no a one-way causal arrow, from the lenvironment to the living organism and vice versa. According to Prodi in the lif... see more

Attention and Consciousness

The human is an animal that refers to itself as an “I”. According to Descartes, the subject is an axiom, and everything else follows from this primordial certainty. This is a dualism: to postulate an I as separate from the natural world. Prodi rejects this dualism. The challenge of Prodi is to find ... see more

The Origin of Language

How does the transition between the proto-semiosic material relation, established between two molecules, and a historical-natural language happen, and what changes does it bring? How much in common do cellular semiosis and human semiosis have? It is necessary to understand how Prodi explains the evo... see more

From Complementarity to Semiosis

Giorgio Prodi poses a fundamental philosophical problem: how was the emergence of immaterial meaning possible within the world of material things? In order to answer this question, Prodi develops an original relational ontology. The world is made of relations between things, not of things. The world... see more

The Biological Model: For an Anti-Cartesian Semiotics

For Prodi, the fundamental semiotic interaction obtains between two molecules. The first selectively “reads” some superficial characteristics of the second, allowing it to establish a link. The fact that a link between two molecules is possible makes the second molecule “meaningful” for the first . ... see more

The Line and the Circle

This chapter describes Prodi’s peculiar strategy to explain life phenomena. This is a model based on the concept of relation or biological meaning that always privileges the relation over the terms of the relation. For Prodi a relation is never a one-way affair, but, on the contrary, it is always a ... see more

Scientist Because Philosopher, Philosopher Because Scientist

Why did Prodi, while engaged in his scientific work, begin to study and to write philosophy? In this chapter, I will attempt to answer this question. The guiding idea is that Prodi realized that, in order to truly be a scientist, one needs to reflect on what it means to be a scientist. Otherwise, th... see more

Life

In this chapter, we will present the main elements of Giorgio Prodi’s life, and we will reconstruct the entire and complex picture of Prodi as an intellectual: a scientist, a philosopher, a novelist.

Introduction

The natural world, the world of things, is a full world. It is full because everything is in contact with something else, because in the world there is nothing but material events. If the world is such, then what is the meaning of a sign? A sign, in fact, is a sending to; it stands for something tha... see more

Conclusion: Prodi and Italian Thought

In this final chapter, I will place the figure of Prodi as a natural philosopher in the wider context of Italian philosophy. Indeed, his originality and his commitment to science notwithstanding, Prodi has always been a philosopher engaged, in a more or less explicit manner, in dialogue with the Ita... see more

Aesthetic Experience and the Problem of the Sacred

The human world is the world of language, i.e. of knowledge. To know means to formulate a hypothesis, to then be either verified or falsified. This also means that the “boundaries” of the world are not fixed but shift with the progress of knowledge. But this also entails that it is knowledge itself ... see more

Language and Ethics

The biological ground of ethics, according to Prodi, should not be sought in feelings of empathy or altruism. On the contrary, human ethics is profoundly “unnatural”, precisely because it is unbound from any genetic principle. As a matter of fact, if there was such a “natural” morality, there would ... see more

Similar books and articles

Giorgio Prodi tsirkulaarne semioosis. Kokkuvõte.Felice Cimatti - 2000 - Sign Systems Studies 28:379-379.
The circular semiosis of Giorgio Prodi.Felice Cimatti - 2000 - Sign Systems Studies 28:351-378.
The circular semiosis of Giorgio Prodi.Felice Cimatti - 2000 - Sign Systems Studies 28:351-378.
Material bases of signification.Giorgio Prodi - 1988 - Semiotica 69 (3-4):191-242.
La biologia e il diritto alla vita.Giorgio Prodi - 1983 - Rivista di Filosofia 25:186.
The ontology and politics of exception: reflections on the work of Giorgio Agamben.Bruno Gulli - 2007 - In Matthew Calarco & Steven DeCaroli (eds.), Giorgio Agamben: sovereignty and life. Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press. pp. 219--40.
Outline of an Uexküllian bio-ontology.Marlen Tonnessen - 2001 - Sign Systems Studies 29 (2):683-690.
Mimesis and Metaphor.Andreas Weber - 2004 - Sign Systems Studies 32 (1-2):297-307.

Analytics

Added to PP
2020-02-03

Downloads
5 (#1,514,558)

6 months
4 (#800,606)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

References found in this work

No references found.

Add more references