Canadian Journal of Philosophy 10 (4):587-592 (1980)
AbstractOften Bertrand Russell defends his view that names differ from descriptions in that names have meaning but descriptions do not by using a “proof.” Recently in this journal it has been debated whether Russell's “proof” fails or not. The familiar objection to Russell's argument is that it is circular or it involves a sense/reference equivocation. Avrum Stroll suggests a novel criticism by making use of a “mirror argument“ which attempts to show that Russell's argument can be used to conclude that "Scott" has no meaning, and that thus the argument proves too much or nothing. Robert Fahrnkopf defends Russell's argument, but, I believe, he does not go far enough in his defense. So it will be useful to carry this debate a few steps further.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
References found in this work
No references found.
Citations of this work
No citations found.
Similar books and articles
Alfred Russel Wallace: An Anthology of His Shorter Writings by Alfred Russel Wallace; Charles H. Smith. [REVIEW]Jane Camerini - 1995 - Isis 86:126-127.
Alfred Russel Wallace. On the Organic Law of Change: A Facsimile Edition and Annotated Transcription of Alfred Russel Wallace's Species Notebook of 1855–1859. Annotated by, James T. Costa. Xii + 573 Pp., Illus., Apps., Bibl., Index. Cambridge, Mass./London: Harvard University Press, 2013. $49.95. [REVIEW]Martin Fichman - 2014 - Isis 105 (3):663-664.
Sequent Reconstruction in LLM—A Sweepline Proof.R. Banach - 1995 - Annals of Pure and Applied Logic 73 (3):277-295.
Proof in Mathematics: An Introduction.James Franklin - 1996 - Sydney, Australia: Quakers Hill Press.
Descartes's Ontological Proof of God's Existence.Cecilia Wee - 2012 - British Journal for the History of Philosophy 20 (1):23-40.
Completeness of MLL Proof-Nets W.R.T. Weak Distributivity.Jean-Baptiste Joinet - 2007 - Journal of Symbolic Logic 72 (1):159 - 170.
Descartes's Ontological Proof of God's Existence.Cecilia Wee - 2012 - British Journal for the History of Philosophy 20 (1):23 - 40.
Proofs and Rebuttals: Applying Stephen Toulmin's Layout of Arguments to Mathematical Proof.Andrew Aberdein - 2006 - In Marta Bílková & Ondřej Tomala (eds.), The Logica Yearbook 2005. Filosofia. pp. 11-23.
Proof and Sanction in Mill's Utilitarianism.Stephen Cohen - 1990 - History of Philosophy Quarterly 7 (4):475 - 487.
Proof Theory: A Selection of Papers From the Leeds Proof Theory Programme 1990.Peter Aczel, Harold Simmons & Stanley S. Wainer (eds.) - 1992 - Cambridge University Press.