HORIZON. Studies in Phenomenology 9 (2):513-531 (2020)
Authors |
|
Abstract |
This essay critically assesses Roman Ingarden’s 1915 review of the second edition of Edmund Husserl’s Logical Investigations. I elucidate and critique Ingarden’s analysis of the differences between the 1901 first edition and the 1913 second edition. I specifically examine three tenets of Ingarden’s interpretation. First, I demonstrate that Ingarden correctly denounces Husserl’s claim that he only engages in an eidetic study of consciousness in 1913, as Husserl was already performing eidetic analyses in 1901. Second, I show that Ingarden is misguided, when he asserts that Husserl had fully transformed his philosophy into a transcendental idealism in the second edition. While Husserl does appear to adopt a transcendental phenomenology by asserting–in his programmatic claims–that the intentional content and object are now included in his domain of research, he does not alter his actual descriptions of the intentional relationship in any pertinent manner. Third, I show Ingarden correctly predicts many of the insights Husserl would arrive at about logic in his late philosophy. This analysis augments current readings of the evolution of Ingarden’s philosophy, by more closely examining the development of his largely neglected early thought. I execute this critical assessment by drawing both from Husserl’s later writings and from recent literature on the Investigations. By doing so, I hope to additionally demonstrate how research on the Investigations has matured in the one hundred years since the release of that text, while also presenting my own views concerning these difficult interpretative issues.
|
Keywords | Ingarden Husserl phenomenology Logical Investigations transcendental reduction logical grammar essence |
Categories | (categorize this paper) |
DOI | 10.21638/2226-5260-2020-9-2-513-531 |
Options |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Download options
References found in this work BETA
Ideen Zu Einer Reinen Phänomenologie Und Phänomenologischen Philosophie.Edmund Husserl - 1950 - Felix Meiner Verlag.
Husserl’s 1901 and 1913 Philosophies of Perceptual Occlusion: Signitive, Empty, and Dark Intentions.Thomas Byrne - 2020 - Husserl Studies 36 (2):123-139.
Husserl-Chronik: Denk- und Lebensweg Edmund Husserls.Karl Schuhmann - 1977 - Tijdschrift Voor Filosofie 42 (4):828-828.
A Controversy Over the Existence of Fictional Objects: Husserl and Ingarden on Imagination and Fiction.Witold Płotka - 2020 - Journal of the British Society for Phenomenology 51 (1):33-54.
View all 34 references / Add more references
Citations of this work BETA
The Meaning of Being: Husserl on Existential Propositions as Predicative Propositions.Thomas Byrne - 2022 - Axiomathes 32 (1):123-139.
Similar books and articles
Erwartungshorizont: Über eine literarische Hermeneutik, die Ingarden nie schrieb.Gerardo Arguelles-Fernandez - 2017 - Meta: Research in Hermeneutics, Phenomenology, and Practical Philosophy 9 (1):137-164.
Roman Ingarden's Review of the Second Edition of Husserl's Logical Investigations.Arthur Szylewicz - 1993 - Husserl Studies 10 (1):1-12.
Roman Ingarden. Ontology From a Phenomenological Point of View.Arkadiusz Chrudzimski - 2004 - Reports on Philosophy 22:121-142.
Genshogaku-teki na Imi no Riron: Husserl kara Ingarden made.Arkadiusz Chrudzimski - 2009 - Gendai Shiso (The Review of Contemporary Thought) 37 (16):66-88.
The Evolution of Husserl’s Semiotics: The Logical Investigations and its Revisions (1901-1914).Thomas Byrne - 2018 - Bulletin d'Analyse Phénoménologique 14:1-23.
Fictions and the Spatiotemporal World—in the Light of Ingarden.Ingvar Johansson - 2010 - Polish Journal of Philosophy 4 (2):81-103.
Phänomenologie Und Realismus. Die Frage Nach der Wirklichkeit Im Streit Zwischen Husserl Und Ingarden.Vittorio De Palma - 2017 - Husserl Studies 33 (1):1-18.
La Controverse Idéalisme-Réalisme Lettre À Husserl Sur la 6e Recherche Logique Et l'Idéalisme ; Remarques Sur le Problème "Idéalisme-Réalisme" ; des Motifs Qui Ont Conduit Husserl À l'Idéalisme Transcendantal ; Qu'y a-T-Il de Nouveau Dans la Krisis de Husserl? Précédé de, Phénoménologie Et Ontologie Chez Roman Ingarden Par Patricia Limido-Heulot.Roman Ingarden & Patricia Limido-Heulot - 2001
El nacimiento de la fenología las investigaciones lógicas (1900-1901) de Edmund Husserl a los 100 años de su publicación. [REVIEW]Gustavo Leyva - 2000 - Signos Filosóficos 4:11-25.
Edmund Husserl: Briefe an Roman Ingarden. Mit Erläuterungen und Erinnerungen an Husserl. Herausgegeben von Roman Ingarden.Martinus Nijhoff. [REVIEW]Paul Gorner - 1971 - Journal of the British Society for Phenomenology 2 (1):84-87.
A Controversy Over the Existence of Fictional Objects: Husserl and Ingarden on Imagination and Fiction.Witold Płotka - 2020 - Journal of the British Society for Phenomenology 51 (1):33-54.
Truth, Concept Empiricism, and the Realism of Polish Phenomenology.Arkadiusz Chrudzimski - 2008 - Polish Journal of Philosophy 2 (1):23-34.
Constitution and Ontology: Some Remarks on Husserl's Ontological Position in the Logical Investigations.Dan Zahavi - 1992 - Husserl Studies 9 (2):111-124.
Analytics
Added to PP index
2020-12-16
Total views
61 ( #185,096 of 2,498,173 )
Recent downloads (6 months)
19 ( #44,418 of 2,498,173 )
2020-12-16
Total views
61 ( #185,096 of 2,498,173 )
Recent downloads (6 months)
19 ( #44,418 of 2,498,173 )
How can I increase my downloads?
Downloads