Modern Intellectual History 7 (2):479-494 (2010)
AbstractThere is no conservative thought in America, only “irritable mental gestures which seek to resemble ideas,” wrote Lionel Trilling in 1950, thus providing a generation of historians with a convenient set piece to demonstrate the inadequacies of mid-century liberalism and its blindness to the nascent conservative intellectual movement gathering strength and purpose just as Trilling wrote. Two excellent new books about American intellectual history cast this quote in yet another light. Patrick Allitt's The Conservatives: Ideas and Personalities throughout American History carefully documents a centuries-long tradition of conservative thought in America, from the founding era through the end of the twentieth century. In The Conservative Turn: Lionel Trilling, Whittaker Chambers, and the Lessons of Anti-Communism, Michael Kimmage asserts that Trilling himself be considered a source of conservative ideas in postwar America. Taken together, the books by Allitt and Kimmage indicate that a new cycle of writing about conservative thought has reached full flower. For far too long, the field of conservative intellectual history has been dominated by the figure of George Nash, author of the classic 1976 The Conservative Intellectual Movement in America since 1945. These books provide an updated and more critically sophisticated way to examine the terrain Nash strode alone for so long. More significantly, they indicate that intellectual historians are ready to consider conservatism in dialogue with liberalism, bringing new balance to the study of American ideas. Furthermore, both books, Kimmage's in particular, suggest that some of what we are calling conservative and liberal might be flying under the wrong flag. The key to sorting out the confusion will be drawing a more careful distinction between conservatism as a “movement” and as a body of ideas, and looking at both conservatisms as part of a typically American response to historical change, rather than as an exotic and abberant specimen.
Similar books and articles
In Search of a Usable Past: Conservative Thought in America.Patrick Allitt & Michael Kimmage - 2010 - Modern Intellectual History 7 (2):479-494.
How Anticommonism ‘Cemented’ the American Conservative Movement in a Liberal Age of Conformity, 1945–64.Lee Haddigan - 2010 - Libertarian Papers 2:7.
The Search for Historical Meaning: Hegel and the Postwar American Right.Paul Gottfried - 1986. - Northern Illinois University Press.
Godless Capitalism: Ayn Rand and the Conservative Movement.Jennifer Burns - 2004 - Modern Intellectual History 1 (3):359-385.
The Conservative Intellectual Movement in America Since 1945, by George H. Nash.Philip Jenkins - 1999 - The Chesterton Review 25 (1/2):131-133.
Conservative Reactions to Multicultural America.Brent A. Nelson & Conservative Citizens' Foundation - 1997 - Conservative Citizens' Foundation.
The Rhetoric of History and Definition: The Political Thought of Richard M. Weaver.Brenan Ryan Nierman - 1993 - Dissertation, Georgetown University
The Conservative Movement in America: Redeeming the Time or Serving the System?Mark Wegierski - 2009 - Telos: Critical Theory of the Contemporary 2009 (148):173-177.
Traditionalist Dissent: The Reorientation of American Conservatism, 1865–1900*: Gillis J. Harp.Gillis J. Harp - 2008 - Modern Intellectual History 5 (3):487-518.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads