In Fiona Leigh (ed.), Themes in Plato, Aristotle, and Hellenistic Philosophy, Keeling Lectures 2011-2018. University of Chicago Press. pp. 149-206 (2021)
AbstractIn this extended essay, I argue that Frege plagiarized the Stoics --and I mean exactly that-- on a large scale in his work on the philosophy of logic and language as written mainly between 1890 and his death in 1925 (much of which published posthumously) and possibly earlier. I use ‘plagiarize' (or 'plagiarise’) merely as a descriptive term. The essay is not concerned with finger pointing or casting moral judgement. The point is rather to demonstrate carefully by means of detailed evidence that there are numerous (over a hundred) and extensive parallels both in formulation and --more importantly-- in content between the Stoics and Frege, parallels so plentiful that one would be hard pressed to brush them off as coincidence. These parallels include several that appear to occur in no other modern works that were published before Frege’s own and were accessible to him. Additionally, a cluster of corroborating historical data is adduced to support the suggestion, showing how easy it would have to been for Frege to plagiarize the Stoics. This (first) part of the essay is easy to read and vaguely entertaining, or so I hope.
Similar books and articles
Frege on Truth, Assertoric Force and the Essence of Logic.Dirk Greimann - 2014 - History and Philosophy of Logic 35 (3):272-288.
Truth, assertion, and the horizontal: Frege on "the essence of logic".William W. Taschek - 2008 - Mind 117 (466):375-401.
Frege's judgement stroke.Nicholas J. J. Smith - 2000 - Australasian Journal of Philosophy 78 (2):153 – 175.
The Nature of Assertoric-Force and the Truth in Logic: An Elucidation of Fregean Truth in the Light of Husserl's Theory of Doxic-Modification.Gao Song - 2011 - Organon F: Medzinárodný Časopis Pre Analytickú Filozofiu 18 (4):423-446.
Stoic logic and multiple generality.Susanne Bobzien & Simon Shogry - 2020 - Philosophers' Imprint 20 (31):1-36.
A caracterização da lógica pela força assertórica em Frege. Resposta a Marco Ruffino.Dirk Greimann - 2012 - Manuscrito 35 (1):61-83.
Formality of logic and Frege’s Begriffsschrift.Daniele Mezzadri - 2019 - Canadian Journal of Philosophy 49 (2):182-207.
Is Judgment Stroke the Sign of Assertoric Force?: Clarifying a Problem in Frege's Logic through Husserl's "Glaubensmodifikation".Song Gao - 2011 - Modern Philosophy (1):80-87.
Frege and the Surprising History of Logic: Introduction to Claude Imbert, "Gottlob Frege, One More Time".Emily Grosholz - 2000 - Hypatia 15 (4):151-155.
Frege and the Surprising History of Logic: Introduction to Claude Imbert, “Gottlob Frege, One More Time”.Emily Grosholz - 2000 - Hypatia 15 (4):151-155.
Hans Sluga (ed.), The philosophy of Frege. A four-volume collection of scholarly articles on all aspects of Frege's philosophy, vol.1: General assessments and historical accounts of Frege's philosophy, vol.2: Logic and foundations of mathematics in Frege's philosophy, vol.3: Meaning and ontology in Frege's philosophy, vol.4: Sense and reference in Frege's philosophy. [REVIEW]Jan Wolenński - 1997 - Erkenntnis 46 (3):407-410.
Frege and the analysis of thoughts.Pieranna Garavaso - 1991 - History and Philosophy of Logic 12 (2):195-210.
Frege and the surprising history of logic: Introduction to Claude Imbert, "Gottlob Frege, one more time".Emily Grosholz - 2000 - Hypatia 15 (4):151-155.
Added to PP
Historical graph of downloads
Citations of this work
La sintassi del cosmo: osservazioni su un volume recente (Review of Ada Bronowski, The Stoics on Lekta, OUP 2019). [REVIEW]Michele Alessandrelli - 2021 - Elenchos: Rivista di Studi Sul Pensiero Antico 42 (2):375-396.
References found in this work
A System of Logic, Ratiocinative and Inductive.John Stuart Mill - 1843 - University of Toronto Press.
An Investigation of the Laws of Thought: On Which Are Founded the Mathematical Theories of Logic and Probabilities.George Boole - 1951 - London, England: Cambridge University Press.
Principia Mathematica.Alfred North Whitehead & Bertrand Russell - 1910 - Cambridge, England: University Press.