Tensions in a certain conception of just war as law enforcement

Res Publica 14 (4):303-311 (2008)
  Copy   BIBTEX


Many just war theorists (call them traditionalists) claim that just as people have a right to personal self-defense, so nations have a right to national-defense against an aggressive military invasion. David Rodin claims that the traditionalist is unable to justify most defensive wars against aggression. For most aggressive states only commit conditional aggression in that they threaten to kill or maim the citizens of the nation they are invading only if those citizens resist the occupation. Most wars, then, claimed to be justified by the traditionalist fail to meet the proportionality criterion. Thus, a just war, for Rodin, is best conceived of as a punitive war of law enforcement, not as a war of national-defense. I argue that Rodin does not have a case against the traditionalist. If national-defense is a disproportionate response to conditional aggression, then punitive war is a disproportionate response as well. Furthermore, the belief that punitive war is a proportionate response to conditional aggression underscores the traditionalist’s view that self-determination, cultural identity and the like are of sufficient value to defend by means of lethal force. I end the paper by very briefly sketching an account, different from that of Rodin’s, of how individual nations can be justified in waging wars of law enforcement.

Similar books and articles

War and Self-Defense.David Rodin - 2004 - Ethics and International Affairs 18 (1):63–68.
Defining War for the 21st Century.Steven Metz & Phillip R. Cuccia (eds.) - 2011 - Strategic Studies Institute, U.S. Army War College.
Waging Defensive War: The Idea and its Normative Importance.Joseph Boyle - 2011 - Journal of Military Ethics 10 (3):148-159.
Taking Terrorism and ROE Seriously.Ted Westhusing - 2003 - Journal of Military Ethics 2 (1):1-19.
Killing in War: A Reply to Walzer.Jeff McMahan - 2006 - Philosophia 34 (1):47-51.
Objecting Morally.C. A. J. Coady - 1997 - The Journal of Ethics 1 (4):375-397.
Blair on Rodin: Rejoinder.Per Albert Ilsaas - 2008 - Res Publica 14 (4):313-316.


Added to PP

214 (#57,404)

6 months
44 (#24,560)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Jacob Blair
California State University, Hayward

References found in this work

War and Self Defense.David Rodin - 2002 - Oxford University Press.
War and Self Defense.David Rodin - 2002 - Oxford University Press UK.
War and Self-Defense.David Rodin - 2004 - Ethics and International Affairs 18 (1):63–68.
On the Moral Equality of Combatants.Jeff McMahan - 2006 - Journal of Political Philosophy 14 (4):377–393.
War as Self-Defense.Jeff McMahan - 2004 - Ethics and International Affairs 18 (1):75-80.

View all 11 references / Add more references