Trolleys, Transplants and Inequality: An Egalitarian Proposal

Erkenntnis 87 (4):1737-1751 (2022)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

This paper deals with the core version of the Trolley Problem. In one case many people favor an act which will bring about the death of one person but save five other persons. In another case most people would refuse to “sacrifice” one person in order to save five other lives. Since the two cases seem similar in all relevant respects, we have to explain and justify the diverging verdicts. Since I don’t find current proposals of a solution convincing, I propose an alternative one according to which —but not —violates two forms of equality. I also test the underlying egalitarian principle against other cases. I argue that it offers a good explanation and also a normative justification of our intuitive verdicts about the cases.

Similar books and articles

Fairness and the Puzzle of Disability.Greg Bognar - 2018 - Theoria 84 (4):337-355.
The Unit and Currency of Egalitarian Concern.David O’Brien - 2019 - Journal of Moral Philosophy 16 (5):613-643.
Intentions and Trolleys.Joseph Shaw - 2006 - Philosophical Quarterly 56 (222):63 - 83.
Two Conceptions of Inequality.Caj Strandberg - 2001 - Philosophical Papers 30 (2):169–199.
On the Usefulness of Luck Egalitarian Arguments for Global Justice.Christian Schemmel - 2008 - Global Justice Theory Practice Rhetoric 1:54-67.
On the Usefulness of Luck Egalitarian Arguments for Global Justice.Christian Schemmel - 2008 - Global Justice: Theory Practice Rhetoric 1:54-67.
Dimensions of Equality.Dennis Mckerlie - 2001 - Utilitas 13 (3):263.
Inequality.Larry S. Temkin - 1993 - Oxford University Press. Edited by Louis P. Pojman & Robert Westmoreland.
On the Scope of Egalitarian Justice.Heath Joseph - 2006 - Les Ateliers de L’Ethique 1 (1):21-41.
Plural voting and political equality: A thought experiment in democratic theory.Trevor Latimer - 2018 - European Journal of Political Theory 17 (1):1474885115591344.
Saving Lives and Respecting Persons.Greg Bognar & Samuel J. Kerstein - 2010 - Journal of Ethics and Social Philosophy 5 (2):1-21.

Analytics

Added to PP
2020-08-18

Downloads
602 (#26,364)

6 months
327 (#5,378)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Peter Baumann
Swarthmore College