Gorgias' defense: Plato and his opponents on rhetoric and the good

Southern Journal of Philosophy 48 (1):95-121 (2010)
  Copy   BIBTEX


This paper explores in detail Gorgias' defense of rhetoric in Plato 's Gorgias, noting its connections to earlier and later texts such as Aristophanes' Clouds, Gorgias' Helen, Isocrates' Nicocles and Antidosis, and Aristotle's Rhetoric. The defense as Plato presents it is transparently inadequate; it reveals a deep inconsistency in Gorgias' conception of rhetoric and functions as a satirical precursor to his refutation by Socrates. Yet Gorgias' defense is appropriated, in a streamlined form, by later defenders of rhetoric such as Isocrates and Aristotle. They present it as an effective reductio against a critique of rhetoric that depends on the "harm criterion." This is puzzling, since Plato 's own critique of rhetoric does not depend on the harm criterion. On the other hand, Plato does seem to embrace the harm criterion as a more general principle—as if pre-emptively embracing the reductio —in his arguments about the good in the Meno and Euthydemus. Nonetheless, Isocrates and Aristotle seem to be deliberately misreading Plato on rhetoric: where he intends to criticize its intrinsic nature, they respond as if he were merely complaining about its contingent effects

Similar books and articles


Added to PP

913 (#10,661)

6 months
92 (#16,746)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Rachel Barney
University of Toronto, St. George

References found in this work

Plato: Complete Works.J. M. Cooper (ed.) - 1997 - Hackett.
Plato's ethics.Terence Irwin - 1995 - New York: Oxford University Press.
"Gorgias" and "Phaedrus": Rhetoric, Philosophy, and Politics. Plato - 2017 - Ithaca: Cornell University Press. Edited by James H. Nichols & Plato.
Cause and explanation in ancient Greek thought.R. J. Hankinson - 1998 - New York: Oxford University Press.

View all 38 references / Add more references