Hand Over Fist: The Failure of Stoic Rhetoric

Classical Quarterly 38 (2):392-427 (1988)
  Copy   BIBTEX


Students of Stoic philosophy, especially of Stoic ethics, have a lot to swallow. Virtues and emotions are bodies; virtue is the only good, and constitutes happiness, while vice is the only evil; emotions are judgements ; all sins are equal; and everyone bar the sage is mad, bad and dangerous to know. Non-Stoics in antiquity seem for the most part to find these doctrines as bizarre as we do. Their own philosophical or ideological perspectives, and the criticisms of the Stoa to which these gave rise, are no less open to criticism than are the paradoxes and puzzles under attack – but they may be, often are, better documented, less provocatively attention-begging, or simply more familiar. Even disputes within the Stoa can be obscured or distorted by modern prejudices. Posidonius rejected Chrysippus' theory of a unitary soul, one rational through and through, on the grounds that such a theory could not satisfactorily account for the genesis of bad – excessive and irrational – emotions, the πάθη. Posidonius' own Platonising, tripartite soul feels more familiar to us because the Republic tends to be a set text rather more often than do the fragments of Chrysippus' de anima; and the balance in Plato's favour is unlikely to change. When Posidonius wrote, on the other hand, the Chrysippean soul was school orthodoxy, and Platonism the latest thing in radical chic.

Similar books and articles

Hand Over Fist: The Failure of Stoic Rhetoric.Catherine Atherton - 1988 - Classical Quarterly 38 (02):392-.
Stoic Philosophy.John M. Rist - 1969 - London: Cambridge University Press.
Plotinus and Posidonius.R. E. Witt - 1930 - Classical Quarterly 24 (3-4):198-207.
Plotinus and Posidonius.R. E. Witt - 1930 - Classical Quarterly 24 (3-4):198-.
Stoic Gunk.Daniel P. Nolan - 2006 - Phronesis 51 (2):162-183.
Why take chemistry stoically? The case of posidonius.Ernesto Paparazzo - 2007 - Foundations of Chemistry 10 (1):63-75.
Plato and the Stoics.Alex Long (ed.) - 2013 - Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Early Stoic Determinism.Susanne Bobzien - 2005 - Revue de Métaphysique et de Morale 4 (4):489-516.


Added to PP

826 (#18,561)

6 months
239 (#10,445)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?

Author's Profile

Catherine Atherton
University of California, Los Angeles

References found in this work

Stoic Philosophy.Pamela M. Huby - 1971 - Philosophical Quarterly 21 (82):75-75.
Education in Ancient Rome.S. F. Bonner - 1978 - British Journal of Educational Studies 26 (3):278-279.
Rhetoric in Greco-Roman Education.Donald Lernen Clark - 1959 - Science and Society 23 (1):69-71.

View all 7 references / Add more references