Three Kinds of Constructionism: The Role of Metaphor in the Debate over Niche Constructionism

Biological Theory 10 (2):103-115 (2015)
  Copy   BIBTEX

Abstract

Throughout the years a lively debate has flourished around niche construction theory. A source of contention has been the distinction between narrow and broad construction activities proposed by critics. Narrow construction is limited to the production of evolutionarily advantageous artifacts while broad construction refers to construction activities that have an impact on the ecosystem but offer little or negative adaptive feedback to the organisms. The first has been acknowledged as relevant to evolutionary studies in that it increases species’ fitness and it is genetically inherited, while the second has been dismissed as accessory and irrelevant. I argue this distinction is unsatisfactory and leads to misinterpreting the achievements of niche construction theory. Instead I propose a three-tier categorization of constructionism (literal, analogical, and figurative) based on the analysis of the metaphor of construction itself. I show metaphors are not a mere rhetorical device but represent an instrument through which theories evolve and introduce new elements. In fact through this categorization I will be able to highlight two innovative features of constructionism: the introduction of reciprocal causation as a main causal framework and the expansion of studies about evolution to large frameworks involving multiple levels of biological organization. I will show their role in each of the three kinds of construction in order to offer a better understanding of the distinctive features of the niche construction approach. The innovations introduced encourage the revision of the concepts of adaptation and enlarge the range of phenomena to be considered relevant in biological studies.

Links

PhilArchive



    Upload a copy of this work     Papers currently archived: 90,593

External links

Setup an account with your affiliations in order to access resources via your University's proxy server

Through your library

Similar books and articles

Comment: Constructionisms?Luc Faucher - 2013 - Emotion Review 5 (4):374-378.
Procedure, reflexivity and social constructionism.Philip Manning - 1998 - In Irving Velody & Robin Williams (eds.), The Politics of Constructionism. Sage Publications. pp. 159--167.
Part III applying constructionism.Ian Burkitt - 1998 - In Irving Velody & Robin Williams (eds.), The Politics of Constructionism. Sage Publications. pp. 121.
Further routes to psychological constructionism.Courtney Humeny, Deirdre Kelly & Andrew Brook - 2012 - Behavioral and Brain Sciences 35 (3):153-154.
Social Constructionism as a Political.Torn Shakespeare - 1998 - In Irving Velody & Robin Williams (eds.), The Politics of Constructionism. Sage Publications. pp. 168.
The paradox of historical constructionism.Michael E. Hobart - 1989 - History and Theory 28 (1):43-58.
Irony and origami.Nigel Edley - 2007 - Philosophy of the Social Sciences 37 (1):100-104.
The limits of social constructionism.Stephen Turner - 1998 - In Irving Velody & Robin Williams (eds.), The Politics of Constructionism. Sage Publications. pp. 109--120.
Part IV the politics of constructionism.Mitchell Dean - 1998 - In Irving Velody & Robin Williams (eds.), The Politics of Constructionism. Sage Publications. pp. 182.
The Politics of constructionism.Irving Velody & Robin Williams (eds.) - 1998 - Thousand Oaks, Calif.: SAGE Publications.
Making Up Your Mind: The Social Construction of Human Kinds and its Implications.Ronald Jerry Mallon - 2000 - Dissertation, Rutgers the State University of New Jersey - New Brunswick
Radikaler Konstruktivismus und KonstruktionismusRadical constructivism and constructionism.Hans Jürgen Wendel - 1992 - Journal for General Philosophy of Science / Zeitschrift für Allgemeine Wissenschaftstheorie 23 (2):323-352.
The Politics of Constructionism.Mitchell Dean - 1998 - In Irving Velody & Robin Williams (eds.), The Politics of Constructionism. Sage Publications.

Analytics

Added to PP
2015-06-22

Downloads
49 (#287,646)

6 months
3 (#445,838)

Historical graph of downloads
How can I increase my downloads?